FREE SHIPPING in the US - NOW through DEC 20! 
Cart (0) $ 0.00 USD
Search
  • /pages/about-us
    The Beach Plum ~ located away from the rushes of the real world
  • /collections/all
    a fun collection of “everything you want and nothing you need…”
  • /collections/fishers-favorites
    Check out our "Fishers Favorites" always in stock!

Fishers Favorites

Leatherman Fishers Island Belts

Leatherman Fishers Island Belts

Traditional Boys and Mens belt with Navy Fishers Island ribbon on a Khaki cot...
from $ 34.00
S&B Embroidered Zip Code Key Fob
Red/White
Sale

S&B Embroidered Zip Code Key Fob

Our custom FI 06390 needlepoint key fobs give your keys a colorful personalit...
$ 28.50 $ 15.00
Etched Striped FI Carving Boards
Etched Striped FI Carving Boards

Etched Striped FI Carving Boards

Custom crafted in New Canaan, these striped maple and mahogany cutting boards...
from $ 55.00
Tervis Waterbottles - NEW
Tervis Waterbottles - NEW

Tervis Waterbottles - NEW

A NEW size addition to our custom FI emblem family of Tervis Tumblers.  24 oz...
$ 28.00
Harding Lane Fishers Island Caps
Harding Lane Fishers Island Caps

Harding Lane Fishers Island Caps

Baseball caps featuring a navy needlepoint Fishers Island.  Made by Harding L...
$ 35.00
Decoupage Wine Coaster - Historic Fishers Map
Decoupage Wine Coaster - Historic Fishers Map

Decoupage Wine Coaster - Historic Fishers Map

The perfect hostess gift.  This historic map in a bright blue and white is gr...
$ 30.00
Island Cut-out Wooden Ornaments
Palm

Island Cut-out Wooden Ornaments

Made in Maine, these wooden ornaments are the perfect addition to every tree....
$ 16.00
Hooked Race Rock Rug

Hooked Race Rock Rug

The latest design custom made for us by Chandler 4 Corners, this rug features...
$ 135.00
About Us
The Beach Plum is a seasonal store on scenic Fishers Island, New York, away from the rushes of the real world, located in The Old Firehouse on the historic Village Green.Owner Heather Burnham has s...
more →
Wedding Registries
Please contact our store to view a wedding registry or to create your own.  Because only a portion of our products are featured on the website, gift registries are maintained in the store.  We are...
more →
Scroll to top