everything you want and nothing you need 

About Us

The Beach Plum is a seasonal store on scenic Fishers Island, New York, away from the rushes of the real world, located in The Old Firehouse on the historic Village Green.

Owner Heather Burnham has spent many years putting together a fun collection of “everything you want and nothing you need…”  We carry hundreds of different lines and focus on unique items that you just can’t find, just anywhere.

Our customers are our friends, and our family, and we enjoy our time working with them all to find the perfect gift for every occasion.
In our Island store, we have everything from baby presents to wedding gifts, clothing and accessories (both for her and for him), works by local artists and the perfect house present for anyone and any occasion!  We are open weekends from Easter though Christmas and seven days a week from June to September.

The main focus of our web store is our favorite Fishers Island items. It’s our way to provide for our friends both near and far to have a little piece of the Island throughout the year! If you need some assistance in your search for the perfect find, please contact us and we will do our best to help you. We are frequently adding new products and restocking items in high demand, so check back soon if you don't see what you're currently looking for.
We look forward to hearing from you. Happy shopping!

~ Heather and Jamie

Scroll to top